Jump to content


- - - - -

The Failed Shot Thread


  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1 OFFLINE   Mystic

Mystic
  • Gender:Alien
  • Location:Tasmania - West Coast

Posted 15 June 2010 - 12:38 PM

We all like to show off those images we think are at least reasonable, if not good, and we love to show off those shots that even make the photographer go WOW and yay But, how about all those other shots, that don't quite make it, and are normally sent to the trash bin?

It's great to see those shots the photographer is proud to show the world, but can we learn more about that person, their photographic style and perceptions, and maybe even about photography itself, if we show and discuss some of those shots that we consider did not quite make the grade? Perhaps it may even be a useful way for beginners to learn about what others desire in their own photography, as well as having the chance to discuss their own goofs and get feedback.

In this thread we would like to see the shots that you feel are normally trash can. Not the complete screw ups, but those that almost, could have made it, if it wasn't for some aspect not being right. Don't just post the shot, tell us what it is about the shot that killed it for you.

To kick this off, here is one I took during the early stages of sunset yesterday. I actually retrieved this from my trash can and developed it in order to post in this thread.

ANNA4134.jpg

The sun had not quite gone below the western ridge, and there was a beautiful golden glow cast across the land. Mt Lyell, in particular was reflecting the golden light beautifully, and that was what I was trying to capture. I wanted to capture the light on Mt Lyell, as well as the colour of the clouds. Had just wandered out to the front verandah, and was not wearing any shoes, so I did not want to walk down my path to a spot where I can get a clean shot of Lyell, and instead chose to stay on the verandah and try to shoot above the power lines across the street.

The result was that Mt Lyell had a very soft focus, and was way too far down in the frame, caught in semi darkness, and the cloud dominated the shot. The soft focus, almost out of focus, mountain killed the shot for me, as well as the framing.


The secret to getting what you want, is to want what you need

If this website helps you, please consider a donation to help us keep the site running. Site Supporters (over $20 donation) also get ad free browsing


Posted Image

#2 OFFLINE   Cascade

Cascade
  • Gender:Not Telling

Posted 15 June 2010 - 12:58 PM

Hehe.. Nice idea Mystic.. Not sure there's enough room on the server for all my failed shots - especially photo's of birds with "NO" bird in sight - or this one of the Macaque's in Launceston, destined for failure before the camera even came out of the bag, light, shadows, glare and a subject that was liable to dissapear any second... I guess I should stop monkeying around ROFL







#3 OFFLINE   Mystic

Mystic
  • Gender:Alien
  • Location:Tasmania - West Coast

Posted 15 June 2010 - 03:23 PM

Definitely could have been an interesting shot Cascade. Perhaps a strong ND filter might have helped to a degree. For me, that cable would have killed it as well, maybe having moved left to change the angle and remove that from the shot. I do like the critter splashing and jumping though.

If I kept all my stuff ups I would need huge hard drives, but they usually go straight to the bin, which is why that although Shane and I discussed the idea of creating this thread about two weeks ago, it is only now beginning as I kept forgetting to save my failures ROFL
The secret to getting what you want, is to want what you need

If this website helps you, please consider a donation to help us keep the site running. Site Supporters (over $20 donation) also get ad free browsing


Posted Image

#4 OFFLINE   Shane V

Shane V
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Queenstown Tasmania

Posted 16 June 2010 - 11:53 AM

Love the colours in your shot Mystic. I was thinking crop, but seeing as the mountain is so soft on focus no point really...but some people like that. Hey I could possibly use it as a texture...did you bin the original?

That would have been a cool shot Cascade. I couldn't really suggest anything other than what Mystic has, except maybe get down in there with them ROFL

Here's one from me...

not quite right.jpg

For me there is too much light on the image. I'm not sure about the composition. The colour doesn't really turn me on either. I do like part of where it was focused but would have liked to have seen more of the drops in focus. Even though I do sort of like the shot I don't think it has as much of the WOW factor that it needs.

Thought I might add my camera details and settings.
Pentax K20D with a Sigma 24-70 DG EX (the Beast)
F 2.8
1/500 sec
ISO 100
focal length 70mm
Manual control



#5 OFFLINE   exislegirl

exislegirl

    Resident

  • Site Supporter
  • 497 posts
  • Gender:Female

Posted 16 June 2010 - 12:06 PM

Lol, I have so many candidates for this thread... and I'm sure 99% of them are due to me having NFI what I'm doing most of the time. The sad thing is, that anything with more than a handful of function buttons leaves me scratching my head. I even find a mobile phone challenging!

Maybe reading this thread will help people like me. :)

Natalie

#6 OFFLINE   Shane V

Shane V
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Queenstown Tasmania

Posted 16 June 2010 - 12:17 PM

That's why it is here Natalie. :) I also think it may be a good idea for people to put there camera details and settings in just so we can see what they used.

#7 OFFLINE   Mystic

Mystic
  • Gender:Alien
  • Location:Tasmania - West Coast

Posted 16 June 2010 - 12:20 PM

We all have loads Natalie. And I don't think any of us fully understand what we could be doing, though some here have definitely shown a great deal of knowledge. Why not post one or two of the kinds of shots that almost made it for you here, and maybe find out how the shot could have been better captured.

Shane, I kinda like that shot myself, but I have also seen another shot like this of yours that really worked in B & W. This one is certainly one of those maybe, possibly, perhaps....nah!
The secret to getting what you want, is to want what you need

If this website helps you, please consider a donation to help us keep the site running. Site Supporters (over $20 donation) also get ad free browsing


Posted Image

#8 OFFLINE   Shane V

Shane V
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Queenstown Tasmania

Posted 16 June 2010 - 12:22 PM

Yeah I prefer the other one myself. :)




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users